Monday, March 10, 2008

Lone cellist paranoia

Because I was the only cellist at rehearsal this past Thursday night I made a very conscious effort to count and listen even more carefully than usual as we were playing. I felt relaxed and confident, and although there were times when I lost my place (as is usual for me, a novice yet at playing with an orchestra and following a conductor) I thought I handled the situation quite well, without feeling shattered or traumatized. In fact I even wrote “YAY!” and drew a smiley face in my day planner when I got home that night.

I was feeling quite good about it all … that is, until the following evening when I ran into an orchestra member who’d been present at that rehearsal. One of the first things she said to me was, “I heard you had a rough time last night.” My immediate reaction was confusion; I thought maybe she was talking about the traffic or something. Then I realized that she was referring to the fact that I was the only cellist at rehearsal. [She heard I had a rough time. Heard how? Was my playing that bad? Could she hear me getting lost? Was I that much off key that she could hear me, even though she was sitting 2 rows behind me? Did someone else hear me play off key and tell her about it? Was everybody talking about how badly I’d played?]

Without taking obvious offense or questioning her further, I did let her know in no uncertain terms, that I was indeed very satisfied with the rehearsal even though the other two cellists were not present, and that it most certainly was not a “rough” time.

However, later that evening more paranoia set in regarding the rehearsal:

  • Had Maestro asked to play my cello during the break that night because he wanted to amuse himself (he’s done this before; he’s also a cellist) or because he wanted to see what kind of tone my cello is really capable of?
  • When Maestro jangled his car keys in the air during “Washington Post March” and yelled out “KEY SIGNATURE!!” (because it had changed to Ab major) was he directing the pun at me?
  • Did Maestro’s technical suggestion to me (hold fingers closer to fingerboard during a fast repetitive passage) make others think I was having a “rough” night? (Actually, I rather enjoyed the personal attention and positive constructive advice that he gave to me.)

I’ve had several days to ponder all of the above, the outcome being that it’s only served to motivate me further to practice more. So maybe paranoia can be a good thing sometimes.

Labels: , , ,

11 Comments:

At 3/10/2008 9:13 PM, Anonymous celloluv said...

I'm glad your paranoia is turning into something positive. One night in a small ensemble I thought I was going to get booted out of the group because of all my intonation problems. After totally being prepared to leave I talked to the coach and found out he was very pleased. He was thinking he was being helpful and hadn't realized that pointing out every wrong note was getting me frustrated. I think the fact that you felt good about things says it all. The conductor may have been supporting your section since you were holding it down by yourself and that he also was a fellow cellist. And as for the key change. It probably takes more than one person to make it obvious that the key change got missed!! It sounds like you're doing great!

 
At 3/11/2008 7:23 AM, Blogger Gottagopractice said...

I was the only cellist for a stretch of several months in my last orchestra, so can relate to several of your points. I found I had to give myself regular pep talks to counteract the paranoia, but deciding to keep a positive attitude regardless of any technical bobbles worked wonders. I grew a lot during those months - extra motivation is good! I think maybe your fellow orchestra member was just projecting how s/he would have felt to be the lonely only.

 
At 3/11/2008 10:11 AM, Blogger Rallentando said...

I have just read your comment on my blog on 8th March when I described my last orchestra practise, and this post makes me even more admiring of your ability!

 
At 3/11/2008 12:31 PM, Blogger Marisa said...

I used to enjoy hiding in the violin and viola sections of the community orchestra but then realized I was relying on it. Nowadays as the only cellist in the group I can't get away with too much. IMHO I think a little nervous energy from being exposed might be a good thing.

 
At 3/11/2008 3:02 PM, Blogger cellodonna said...

Celloluv, your comment about the key change made a lot of sense and really made me feel better.
GGP, the person who made the “rough night” comment to me probably didn’t even realize the impact it would have, and yes, most likely was just projecting her own idea of being the lonely only.
Rallentando, thank you for the compliment. But I do still have many, many miles to go.
Marisa, I do admire your courage to be the only cellist in a group. Fortunately for me I’m usually not the only cellist present at rehearsals, but I plan to keep this memory current so the motivation from it stays with me.

Thank you all so much for the wonderful support.

 
At 3/11/2008 10:40 PM, Blogger Maricello said...

I think it was in John Holt's book, Never Too Late, that he describes a similar experience, being the only cello in the community orchestra. As I recall, he packed up his cello and went home.

I remember feeling that way in orchestra a few years ago when the six cellos dwindled down to me and one other person during a rehearsal.

But, I stayed, and you stayed, and you probably did very well!

Now, I like being the only cello (or in cello ensemble, the only cellist on a part), but I play mostly in small groups, with not so many eyes/ears on me. :-)

 
At 3/11/2008 11:44 PM, Blogger CelloGeek said...

It sounds to me like the conductor was being encouraging. I hate being the only cellist when there's supposed to be a large group. It sounds like you did very well on your own! I like the little bit of paranoia and fear - it keeps my attention from wandering too much (although I have a lot of trouble counting multiple measures of rest).

 
At 3/12/2008 2:13 AM, Blogger Celliste said...

Hey Donna! Thanks for the tag =) That's really sweet of you! haha, I'm kind of fed up with mathematics inductions and homework, hence that post.I am trying very hard to dig out time admist of all that work indeed! But I'm really enjoying the process of making music. I'm sure you can do well too! Just take those feedbacks positively like you are now =) It's good to give yourself self-affirmation too!

 
At 3/13/2008 9:46 AM, Blogger yarnplayer said...

Sounds like you did very well. I think that the observation made by GGP is correct - the person who made the "rough time" remark may have been expressing her own insecurities.

 
At 3/17/2008 2:18 PM, Blogger MusicGal said...

I'm sure you did great! It's easy to go back over every little thing that happened, and assume that it must have been terrible, but this is probably one of those cases where hindsight ISN'T 20/20!
Hey, and even if it wasn't a perfect rehearsal (is there even such a thing?...) you had to have some guts to stick it out as the only cello. Go Cellodonna!

 
At 4/04/2008 9:15 PM, Blogger allthingspink said...

dont stress it. by you being the only cellist, you automatically become more self-conscious. he was most likely pointing these things out to you because it was easier to fix your minor mistakes and offer suggestions with you being the only one there. dont fret, im sure you did fine. :]
sarah

 

Post a Comment

<< Home